Ruby Justice Thelot Knows How We Can Build a Better Relationship with Our Phones
The internet researcher and adjunct professor at NYU’s forthcoming book, ‘In Defense of Being-On-Line,’ argues that a fun, healthy internet is still possible.
- Written and Photographed by: J Wortham

Ten minutes of Instagram (per day)
One hour of Twitter (per day)
12 movies per year
No TV (at all)
Unlimited books
These are the rules that Ruby Justice Thelot set for himself in 2026 to manage his media consumption, particularly around the internet and social media. How’s he doing? It depends on the day.
The 31-year-old internet researcher was born and raised in Montreal, and came to New York five years ago to teach at New York University where he is an adjunct professor of human-computer interactions who chronically researches being-on-line. He writes it like that, deliberately, as “being-on-line,” a callback to Being and Time, a canonical work by German philosopher Martin Heidegger who theorized that a human’s fundamental understanding of self was deeply impacted by their outer world, cultural environment, and relationships. Thelot hopes to expand that question to the digital. “What happens when so much of the world we inhabit is mediated by technological systems?” he asks. “When how we encounter another person, how we express affection, how we understand ourselves, happens through an interface?”
Thelot first made a name for himself online by sharing unusually succinct and incisive ideas about internet life and culture, establishing new terms and concepts like digitally mediated legibility (also known as “very online,” or the recognizability of screen or social media images and references), the idea of “default fake,” or the post-reality era we are living through, and “connection bloat,” or the way the intimacy of our online communities decays over time as we prioritize followers over friends. (He also calls these figures, brutally, “timeline acquaintances.”) He memorably argued for the archive as better self-representation than the profile, and sees the Oura ring and the self-quantification movement as a portal to dehumanization, and ultimately, death.
Thelot’s first major collection of essays, called In Defense of Being-On-Line, comes out in January from Drawn Down Books, and is a mix of savvy observations, Emily Post-like etiquette recommendations, calls to action to push back against the inevitability of AI encroachment, and compassion for the hyperonline. He teases out the ways the unknowability about the black-boxness of technology in our lives—i.e., what algorithms are surfacing vs. silencing, whether there’s a secret level of Hinge where all the hot people hang out—has led to a mythical, borderline superstitious relationship with the devices and platforms that mediate our lives. His findings are almost always surprising, including his broader call for empathy for the ways people seek closeness through opaque systems and their lightweight (yet meaningful) gestures. For example, he reminds us why interpreting Instagram Story likes is so difficult, almost intentionally chaotic. But we should remember we’re learning a new digital love language, together, and there’s some charm in that.
Ruby and I spoke by phone and over e-mail to discuss the possibility of social media discipline, alternatives to the accelerationists/decelerationists debate, and whether or not we’re in a spiritual crisis, rather than a technological one.

J Wortham
Ruby Justice Thelot
So you’re in San Francisco? It’s interesting to be talking to you about your practice of cyberethnography when you're in the place where it all came from.
Ruby Justice Thelot: Literally the belly of the beast. It’s my first day here, so I haven’t seen much.
Could you tell me a little bit about the term cyberethnographer? Because that was my first time hearing it.
I first encountered it doing research. I was studying Tumblr at the time—and actually I just republished a Tumblr essay, with Tumblr supporting it, and that was five years ago. Some people call it digital ethnography or netnography, but that doesn’t sound as good. Cyberethnography was the proper term for this, and what I would call participant observation [because] I was in a lot of the communities that I was writing about.
How did you figure out that this was something you wanted to devote your time and energy to?
I was working in finance at the time, but in college, I had a meme page. It was called “vivre en appart à 5 minutes de chez ses parents” (translation: living in an apartment 5 minutes away from your parents). And it was a page my friends [and I] had making fun of kids in a private school and whatnot. It was really wonderful, and it was with other people of color, and we were talking about the complexities of being a person of color in those spaces. At its peak, we had 20,000 or 25,000 followers on Facebook. That’s how old it was. The memes were on Facebook, not even on Instagram.
I love that.
I spent a lot of my teenage years on weird Facebook. We never thought anything of it until one day, I got an email from someone at a university in Quebec saying, hey, we’d like for you to come and talk about meme making. And so I realized there was a whole field of study that was studying memes, and studying the internet. I went to the conference, and I gave my spiel about the process of meme making, and my eyes got wide open. And so, I spent the next couple of years working full time writing, doing research, and submitting a bunch of essays and papers to all the different visual humanities journals, going to conferences, internet history, all the different ones where there was any intersection with cyberethnography. That’s really how I started—as an independent researcher.
And how has your relationship to the internet changed over time? It seems that one of your primary ways of accessing the world, processing the world, and understanding the self has been through social media. This is also my way of asking about your social media diet, because you have a very strict social media diet. It’s basically a social media keto diet.
You know, people would assume that I’m on there a lot, but... I’m not really on there. I have [a rule of] 10 minutes per day. Some days I definitely go over. I’ve traveled today, so I’m definitely breaking my rules because I was waiting on the tarmac, but yesterday was a really good day. It depends on what I’m doing. Sometimes it’s thirty-four minutes, or fifty-three. Or a couple of hours. I’m not draconian about it. It’s an aspiration. These are places where we’ve intermingled our main sources of communication, so if I’m posting or I want to respond to something, or if I’m making a plan, I need to go on there and talk to my friends, to know where to meet up and whatnot. By and large, a lot of my insights don’t necessarily come from using the internet so much as looking at people using the internet and asking people why they’re doing the things they do. I like looking at people’s phones. And that’s primarily the way that I interact on most of the internet—looking over people's shoulders.


For many of us who came of age online, it’s really rare to not have a codependent relationship with the internet, in terms of access to knowledge or even using it as a way to dissociate. How much of that is a personal decision?
I love technology and I love social media. But I know that I love it because it is serving me. It helps me get my ideas out there, and I'll meet people, it helps me be inspired, but much like anything, it is that way because I do it in moderation.
We have to recognize the parts that are accretive, or generative for us when we're using social media, and how can we, as users, make sure that we're getting the best [deal], right? Because by and large, the platforms have a mission. And that’s their thing. They are trying to keep you on there to make money.
I think we still have a say in how they treat you with these tools. And my rules were my example, saying, Okay, this is how I want to use my tool, because it's how I want to live my life. I want to be able to feel inspired for ten minutes a day. I want to read interesting thoughts on Twitter for thirty minutes a day. But if I'm spending more than an hour on Twitter, there's a diminishing return to how much information I'm getting. And this is because I know myself. TikTok is such a powerfully tailored platform that if I don't restrict myself—I just use it. I go into a rabbit hole. I just doomscroll for too long. My TikTok algorithm is so good.
I love cooking. There’s a lot of French cooking, all these recipes, a lot of traditional French and Italian cooking that I would not get anywhere else. That's something I'm very, very happy about when I constrain it. Not to compare it to a drug or anything. It’s less like alcohol and more like sugar. If I want to spend the next ten years doing anything, I think it's going to be talking about this idea of learning digital hygiene. In the same way that we teach people how to have oral hygiene with their toothbrushes and flossing. How do we do that for technology?
I think that's what's missing in our conversation about technology. We talk about media literacy, which is about how you read things on the internet. But how do you use your phone conscientiously? Is there some kind of routine or guideline in the same way?
A lot of the work that I do in the book is not necessarily recommendations, but let me name the things that are making [the internet] feel a little bit off. Whether it be “functional divergence” [Ed. note: Which Ruby defines as when a platform does too many things, it gets hard to do any one of them well], or notification bloat. Putting names to these phenomena, so that we have a way to talk about the things you want to control.
I’ve been thinking about your analogy of needing new digital hygiene conditioning and rules, but do you really think most people have enough willpower to regulate their usage of technology? Or even the desire? Or maybe "most" isn’t the goal—just those who want to try and embrace a new paradigm. New York Magazine recently published a piece about aging parents being the most technology-addicted and we keep hearing whispers of youthful Luddites. Maybe it’ll split by demographic, in surprising ways.
Absolutely. I refuse the discourse of disempowerment that pushes users to feel like they are merely puppets controlled by tech. No, we can refuse, we can divest, we can put the phone down. I am a staunch believer in our willpower as citizens, constituents, and consumers. The belief that we (adults) cannot self-regulate is a slippery slope which can only be solved through a parental state dictating what we can and cannot use. (I think we should control these systems with children as they are vulnerable!)
Was there ever an inciting incident where you felt like things had gotten out of control and you needed to wrangle them?
I went through a breakup and Instagram became a very obvious method of coping. I noticed that this is a place where I go to feel assuaged for a little bit. And I was like oh, that’s interesting. My first post on Instagram—I think it might still be up—it’s a poem called Instagram and the last line is “Instagram, I pretend I don’t miss you.” It was the first time I realized that Instagram is not just a platform—there’s something here that I need to study and talk about. It was around the time of my first gallery show, and I was showing digital art at the time. I was selling memes, which was very 2017 of me.

In the book you coin the term “paratechnology” which is the development of technologies to get away from other technologies, and get back the control we’ve lost.
I use Screen Time, which is the most simple digital barrier. That to me is enough. I pulled some data to take a look at, like, why is that technology is becoming not only a popular thing that people are drinking is also a, it’s not like it’s an industry now. But people are now selling the Brick, Yondr, all these different tools for you to prevent you from using your phone. Most Americans say they spend too much time on their phones. Only three percent of people say they spend too little time on their phones. Forty-five percent of people [in the U.S.] have tried to reduce their smartphone time, but only 25 percent of that 45 percent say they’ve been successful. That means a lot of people try and fail. They just can’t do it. And so, they’re looking to external technology as a way to help them.
This is also how capitalism and consumerism work, trying to solve a problem rooted in the same problem. I have a Brick and I used it for a little while. I liked it a lot, but I also felt like what I need is less to do. Having to tap a device to stop myself from using my device made me realize this is not a question of more products, or even willpower. And that’s why I was really interested in your book because I feel like you’re trying to get at some of the internal mechanisms keeping us in these ecosystems.
You talk about one of the reasons that AI is so unbelievably effective is that it can be charming, or funny, or stupid—but people feel an uncanny draw to it because it’s anthropomimetic, meaning, it mimics us, and allows for easy connections to be established. You write: “The system didn’t need to understand the person for the person to feel understood.” For the average person, I don’t think there’s a lot of conscious awareness about why these systems are so seductive and enticing.
It doesn’t have to be this way. Like, the AI can be very, um, nonhumanlike. It can be anti-anthropomimetic. What we need to interrogate is why did we make this decision? There are models that do not answer in natural language. They answer in probabilities. It doesn’t say, hey, Ruby, this thing is blue. It just says, there is a 75 percent chance this is blue. But this method was chosen, perhaps to drive adoption. But it doesn’t have to be this way.
We have chosen this. These paradigms, they’re not inevitable, right? It doesn't have to be this way. This is the path we’ve taken.
There are different architectural paradigms, like the new model JEV created by Diogo Almeida, one of the main architects of ChatGPT. JEV does not generate natural language.
Anthropomimesis, systems that mimic humans, is a design decision. We must not forget that.
In China, the solution has been to ban AI partners or systems that lead to such outcomes. The solution could be market response—refusing to use tools that leave us worse as a society or policy, enacting laws that ensure tech is aligned with society’s best interests.
How do we think about how humanity is evolving or adapting or, you know, becoming more symbiotic with these platforms when there’s no separation?
People are clever. They understand that if they’re in the business of getting attention, they can go make some money or build clout and sing at 14th Street Union Square or on YouTube. If you do that enough, sometimes it works.
Part of it [now] is leaning into the digital. That is a theory that I talk about, a theory of departure. If the “bag” – meaning both social capital and financial capital – is big enough, people are willing to encroach on the real world in order to get the benefits. If I’m a cute girl and I can go into the subway, embarrass myself in front of people, I can do that. People in the vicinity will be like, who’s this girl, what’s she doing? But then you post that online, and you go viral.
It is almost like a calculus of what you lose in embarrassment versus what you gain when you post online.

I like what you said earlier. People are extremely clever, and they understand that they’re in the business of getting attention, and whether that’s because you’re trying to launch a career, or because you’re someone who wants a particular kind of social currency in your field, or even in your community. That’s the motivation for being in the business of sharing. Do you have thoughts on how that impacts the way we understand ourselves? The way we think about our value as people, individual people, if we’re kind of constantly organizing ourselves around attention?
I might say that people are willing to make that trade-off. I think there’s a very thought-out calculus. They’ve seen what it’s done for others, and they’re willing to just try it. At the same time, people are also feeling financial nihilism. A lot of young people feel like there’s no other route. You can do the nine-to-five thing, but it doesn’t really provide the same kind of security that it did before. I knew things had changed when I started seeing a lot of people who were working at Goldman Sachs start making content. I was like, Oh, shit. People are really trying to maximize their avenues to make sure that they survive the capitalist world. People are very aware that they cannot keep all their eggs in the same basket.
One of the things you’re also clearly identifying in this book is that we have all this knowledge at our fingertips, but we still don’t know how to be a good person. We still have trouble answering fundamental questions about who we are. I think it’s ironic that this task of creating versions of ourselves that are marketable or legible to the world isn’t helping us understand who we are any better. Do you think this is actually becoming a spiritual crisis or even a philosophical one that’s not going to be answered by more technology or more information?
This is an ontological crisis, because we now have to reckon with being online.
Damn. Okay, professor!
The good manners of my parents taught me whatever it is, like, they don’t necessarily apply in that realm. I think a big part of the loving chapter, is that even something as simple as communication, that has also been upended by the digital.
Your dad might be like, Why don’t you go to a bar and just talk to a young woman there, and maybe you ask her out for a coffee? It just isn’t like that anymore. We’ve rewired a lot of our mores and behaviors, and there's a new way of life. That’s the crux of it. In the “Loving” chapter I get into the nuances about how some people put different values on whether or not someone engages with your Stories, but there are different ways of understanding these interactions.
I dated somebody for a while who would watch all of my stories and heart all of my posts but never comment. And I wasn’t ever trying to hard launch because I don’t want my personal life to be that public, but I did want a cute comment from time to time. I felt so unseen and also so silly. I felt so validated by that chapter in the book. There is something so charming about remembering that we’re learning a new love language and that different interactions have different meanings for everyone, and it’s not stupid just because it’s a small digital interaction on social media.
The first chapter of this book is about dating my ex-girlfriend and seeing what she expected from me online. I may be a great boyfriend, but I had no idea that I was supposed to do all these things, such as liking her Story. I was dating a Zoomer and being like, Oh, wait, there are new things I’m not aware of.
Did anything surprise you from that time?
People are really out there scheming. I interviewed someone, for instance, who was using Close Friends [to appear like she was] posting to a bunch of people, but really for only one [select] person.
I do this! I have done this. Not a lot, but I have definitely posted a racier photo to close friends and only had one person on there. I love the example you gave of the person who would post a Story claiming that their buddy bailed on their dinner plans and asking if anyone would like to come instead, but only adding the person they wanted to ask out to Close Friends. We’re figuring out how to pass notes, basically. Putting notes in each other’s lockers. It’s so cute to me.
You end the book talking about the rise of technofascism, which is not necessarily a new concept. But you seem a bit resigned to accept that may be our new reality? Are you a techno-pessimist?
I use the term perhaps as a bit of a misnomer. I mean it, in the final essay, “The Telos of Technology,” as the embrace of technology as a guide for the future. This being the accelerationist position. I’m actually hopeful about a third option, the humanist one, wherein technology is bent to the will of man for our empowerment and flowering. I might add this as the final paragraph, lol.
(J Wortham)[https://j-wortham.com/]fit is a filmmaker, writer and visual artist living in Brooklyn. Their nonfiction book, Work of Body, comes out in spring 2027 from One World Books.
- Written and Photographed by: J Wortham
- Date: November 18, 2026

